Demo build: review scores and social quotes are placeholders. Directory and blog are sourced.
Sliced cheese on brown wooden chopping board
Tillamook

Extra Sharp Cheddar

🇺🇸 USA

7.8Overall
score / 10
VerdictExcellent and creamier than Cabot, but less transparent on sustainability and a bit pricier.

Photo: Andra C Taylor Jr / Unsplash. Illustrative, not the actual pack.

Good

  • Creamy texture
  • Co-op owned
  • Consistent quality

Not so good

  • Higher price per ounce
  • Fewer published sustainability numbers

Our review

Milder 'extra sharp' than the label suggests — rounder and butterier. Great for melting, slightly less interesting on its own.

Where it's made

Country
🇺🇸 USA
Region
Oregon
Made at
Tillamook, Oregon
Ingredients
Milk from member dairies
Price
$5.99 · 8 oz · $0.75/oz

Score breakdown

Origin (30%)
9.0
Transparency (15%)
8.0
Green (20%)
6.5
Value (15%)
6.5
Taste (20%)
8.0

Green check

Some green credentials, but below the Green pick threshold.

What people are saying

“Placeholder: one-sentence excerpt from a real post goes here.”

Instagram · @sample_account
View original post ↗

More in Dairy & Cheese

CompetitorScoreOriginGreenTasteUnit price
Cabot — Sharp Cheddar Block8.49.57.58.5$0.69/oz Head-to-head
Black Diamond — Old Cheddar7.39.05.57.5$0.93/oz Head-to-head