Made in Canada vs. Product of Canada: what the label really promises
A Canadian flag on a package tells you little. The wording next to it tells you more, and the two common phrases do not mean the same thing.
The short version
| Label | What it signals for food |
|---|---|
| Product of Canada | All, or virtually all, of the major ingredients, processing and labour are Canadian. |
| Made in Canada | The last substantial transformation happened in Canada. Ingredients may be imported, and the pack should say so. |
A maple leaf on its own is not a claim. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) says a maple leaf does not always mean the product is wholly or partly Canadian.
Product of Canada
For food, the CFIA treats "Product of Canada" and the word "Canadian" the same way: the major ingredients, the processing and the labour should all be Canadian. A common shorthand you will see quoted is that 98% of the direct costs of production must be incurred in Canada. That cost test is set out in the Competition Bureau's guidance for non-food goods, so treat it as a rule of thumb for groceries and check the CFIA wording for food.
Made in Canada
"Made in Canada" is the weaker claim. For food, the test in CFIA guidance is that the last substantial transformation happened in Canada. A product made here from imported flour, sugar or cocoa can qualify. When it does, the label is expected to say whether it was made from imported ingredients, domestic ingredients, or a mix, such as "Made in Canada from imported and domestic ingredients".
Where the sources disagree
Several guides repeat a "51% of costs" threshold for "Made in Canada". The CBC later clarified that the 51% figure applies to non-food products, and the CFIA's food test is the last-substantial-transformation one. We follow the CFIA wording for food. The CFIA has also consulted on revising the food claim guidelines, so check the agency's own page before relying on any threshold, including ours.
What we do with this
- In our directory, "made in Canada" means the plant is in Canada. It does not mean the ingredients are Canadian.
- Our review score has a separate Origin component that looks at ingredient sourcing, so a product made here from imported inputs scores lower than one made here from local inputs.
- Where a list says "verify the label", we repeat that warning on the row.
How to read a pack in ten seconds
- Find the exact phrase: "Product of", "Made in", "Packaged in" or "Distributed by".
- If it says "Made in Canada", look for the "from imported/domestic ingredients" line.
- Ignore the flag and the leaf. They are decoration.